Overflow

[seeks]

I know this question has been posted on several sites, so I figured I would ask the question here, more so for resource purposes.

What overflow do you prefer and why?

Durso - I find this to be the most common, easy, trustworthy and just drill the top and insert air hose to silence - no gurgle
Herbie - best for no noise, but you have to adjust valve
Bean - never used
Maggie Muffler - never used
Other - diy, basically maggie muffler's

 

[Luke_L]

I run dual durso in my system, the vent hose is cut at a specific height, so in the event of a blockage, the water will block the siphon break and go full siphon... lol

 

[Limey]

I used to use the durso but found difficult to keep full syphon lots of surges and gurgling very frustrating to balance.
So last 10 years or so i have used a herbie with an oh shit relief pipe which has actually been utilized about 3 times in past 10 years after a snail or two when for at walk where not needed.

 

[seeks]

I guess my biggest issue is I have 14ft of a horizontal run, so herbie is likely out of the question. Dorasl is likely then.

 

[Luke_L]

I guess my biggest issue is I have 14ft of a horizontal run, so herbie is likely out of the question. Dorasl is likely then.

I used Herbie in my 120, with sump in basement... it just took a while for it to balance itself out after the event of a power outage.